The World of Creativity— Scabbiolo Interviews Franco #3

Seth: Hi Franco, thanks for not abandoning us.

Franco: I am here.

Seth: I hope you are ok today to talk about what you have promised to us: the nature of processes, the creative conflict, and the world of creativeness.

Franco: Yes, thanks for the opportunity. Creativity is a subject that, generally speaking, comes out well when we don’t know what we are talking about. Possibly, this is the only way to talk seriously about it.

Seth: Ok, let’s see how it goes. Let’s start with the nature of processes.

Franco: You remember that in previous interviews we have explored the Worlds of Abandonment, Confusion, Adaptation, and Delusion. These worlds are not static, in the sense of a “picture of the world,” like Money-Kyrle’s concept; they are world processes.

Seth: World processes? Can you say something about that?

Franco: Well, within the analytic process different kinds of change can be distinguished. So much is going on, but four kinds of change stand out: stalemate, transitions, transformations, and creativity. Stalemate is the sensation of being trapped. Transitions are movements from one state to another. The regularity of hours, the spontaneous establishing of ceremony, the rhythms of the beginnings, the middles, and the ends of sessions. Getting used to free association (transitions between one idea and another). Attention-transition from one thing to another, without stopping. All these are kinds of transition, and the rhythms of transition become the ground for more complex changes. Transformations are changes of appearances, changes in form. And creativity is the state of positive capability.

Seth: Didn’t D. W. Winnicott say something about transitions?

Franco: Winnicott developed the concept of transition in a very concrete way when he drew attention to “transitional objects.” A child holds a blanket which smells of the mother, for example, and this serves to help master external reality by facilitating the transition between the comfortable already known, and an extended world with new feelings and new contents.

The setting for the psychoanalytic process generates a kind of transitional space. Sometimes the patient and analyst tacitly agree to remain in the transitional space. Transitions can provide the continuity necessary for the creation and maintenance of change. When the process gets going, transitions play an important role in both maintaining the continuity and in encouraging the patient (because the patient feels these emotional transitions when they happen).

Seth: Can you tell us about transformations? Is it related to Wilfred Bion’s book?

Franco: Bion’s imagination was in full display in his book Transformations, from his own vertex, as it were. Also, Christopher Bollas developed the concept of the “transformational object.” What I have in mind here is clearly contained in the word itself: “trans-formation.” We are talking about a change in form. From an analytic point of view, there is a submerged problem here. It is the idea that beneath change is some kind of a substance that remains constant. Let’s look at this from the perspective of analytic experience, specifically emotional experience. Without question, the analytic process involves transformations, changes of appearances, changes in form. While these kinds of change are more than transitions, transformational processes can be very difficult to see.

Seth: Dreams?

Franco: Yes, that is a good place to start. There are plenty of changes of form in dreams. Very quickly, looking at these kinds of transformations, we can find ourselves transported to the realm of art. Take L. S. Lowry (who painted his family and the industrial and social landscape of Northern England) for example, and the way his inner life is expressed in the external landscapes of his paintings. We can learn from painters how external perception is transformed by what is going on inside the artist. There are many levels in which transformation takes place. When a patient reports a dream, the transformations in the dream are further transformed by the process of verbalization. The images, colours, sounds, joys, or pains, of a dream are transformed into the sounds of verbal language.

The hope for the analytic process is that these forms created by the patient come to be able to hold, in a more permanent way, the emotions, the feelings, of dream experience. Dreams, and the feelings associated with them, tend to disappear very quickly, it is difficult to capture moments of transformation, it is difficult even to notice them, but with practice transformations can be seen, felt, and held. Similarly, when we wake from dreams, there is another transformation. We move from the experience of internal sensations and images into the waking world of form. Again, this is a transformation that can, and should, be felt.

Seth: So, what is the point of focusing on transformations and the feelings they involve?

Franco: When we make the effort, through dreamwork or in artwork, the forms become available to us in a much more permanent way. We write them down, re-make them, mark them, and then we are able to re-cognise them, and to feel them again. In these transformations there is something gained, but there is also something that is lost, abandoned. Indeed, this is indicative of all realms of change. We gain, but we also lose. Something arrives, but something disappears. In the re-telling of dreams, we gain some permanence. The analyst and the patient can look at things together, appreciate them. But it is very difficult to maintain the sensations and the emotions connected with the dream.

Verbal language allows us to add something: meaning, logic, ideas about what the dream contains. But this translation into verbal language is a very complicated process. It includes gross simplifications and it opens up the possibility of error and misunderstanding. The patient has transformed something which is, essentially, emotionally visual, (the dream), into something verbal. In doing so, the patient is creating their own symbolism. A new thing is being made—a different thing. In so far as it is possible, the analyst and patient trace back the transformations, so that they can become aware of, and appreciate, their beauty and usefulness.

Seth: What about metamorphosis?

Franco: Metamorphosis is a special transformation, such as that of magic or by sorcery. Metamorphosis is a fantastic concept in that it can be physical, symbolic, or abstract. The physical, symbolic, and abstract can even merge as in Kafka’s story The Metamorphosis when Gregor Samsa “wakes up.” That blink upon waking, that moment between the vagueness of dreams and the precision of immediate perception, parallels a similar distinction that can be experienced in our waking state: we can choose to see the room we are sitting in as patches of colour, or instead we focus on forms seeing objects and people. This capacity to change perspectives can alert us to assumptions we may be making.

These assumptions do not just take part in our external perception, they also take place internally. It is hard to see that we continue to dream when we are awake.

On the other hand, imagine going to see a Monet exhibition. You perceive the paintings of water lilies. But there is a further stage: you leave the gallery but now you see other things differently. Your perception of colour has changed. Your experience has been transformed.

Seth: Can you say more about that? It is very interesting to me.

Franco: Well, for instance when we are thinking logically in the waking world of objects, we tend to appropriate rather than appreciate objects. And after that, we separate objects from each other. In the dream-vagueness of feelings, however, our experience is transformative and transformational: anger morphs into love, anxiety and fear into joy and tranquility, the pleasant into the unpleasant, and vice versa.

Seth: How can we express what happens in the analytic-creative process? The most important things that go on there are not logical, not binary. So how can we illuminate the process, the transformations that occur during the process?

Franco: Meltzer used to insist that analytic work is an art form. We turn to art, to painting, to music, theatre, cinema, and dance, because they have greater resources for the expression and appreciation of vagueness, ambiguity, and the complexity of feelings.

Seth: Now can we move on to discuss creative change and the creative conflict?

Franco: Remember in our previous interview I said something like, “The Compass can be a method—even a negative method (see Keats’ negative capability)—for illuminating the creativity inherent in becoming.”

Seth: Oh yes, you are referring to Keats’ idea of negative capability?

Franco: Not only that. What is also required in order to create is positive capability.

Seth: What do you mean?

Franco: According to Keats’ Letters, negative capability exists when a person “is capable of being in uncertainties, mysteries, doubts, without any irritable reaching after fact and reason.” But not only Keats illuminated these feelings.

Seth: Who else?

Franco: Many, for example let us here reflect on some advice from Rilke from his classic, Letters to a Young Poet:

“Have patience with everything unresolved in your heart and try to love the questions themselves as if they were locked rooms or books written in a very foreign language. Don’t search for the answers, which could not be given to you now, because you would not be able to live them. And the point is to live everything. Live the questions now. Perhaps then, someday far in the future, you will gradually, without even noticing it, live your way into the answer.”

Keats’ idea of “negative capability” highlights uncertainty, while Rilke highlights creation of answers. This is manifested in the analytic situation, not only from the patient but also from the analyst, who could become irritated because of the uncertainty and cannot have the necessary patience to feel the feelings seriously about a way out. Alongside a negative capability, we must stimulate in ourselves and in our patients a positive capability that allows us to feel the feelings and build something in the mind; not in the sense of action or responding to preformed ideas, but rather to have intuition, to create, and to organize the life and turbulence of emotions.

Seth: What do you mean?

Franco: Because it is so difficult, there is always a kind of pressure. We think there must be some technique or technology that can help us, some machine for making creativeness easier, more straightforward. But I think the most we can do is to create conditions conducive to the creative process, a context where creativeness can take place. For me, this is connected to the question of abandonment, because in the creative process we have to accept and overcome the feeling of being abandoned and waiting for the muse.

This tends to emerge as a “Creative Conflict.” William Blake suggested to us: “I must create a system or be enslaved by another man’s; I will not reason and compare: my business is to create.” Creativeness is not strictly a capacity of the self. We need help, a muse. Finding a genuine guide, like Virgil for Dante in The Divine Comedy, is not as simple as turning on a screen. I feel embarrassed speaking about creativeness because it is only tiny drops, glimpses, that I have experienced. But when I have had such glimpses, they were much more than the experience of a simple transition or even transformation. It was a shocking; it was astonishing. There are only instances of creativeness. Moments. Drops. Manifestations. Emergences.

Seth: Emergences?

Franco: When you are involved in a creative process, something mysterious happens, you seem to be in contact with something which cannot be pinned down, which does not even exist, until you approach the final result, the creature.

In the midst of a process there may be many instances of transition and transformation, but when novelty emerges, we realize that something unprecedented has occurred. Often we find this difficult to accept; we are conservative beings and we hate change. We hate creativity, particularly other people’s creativity. Although, if we can overcome this conservativeness, we can learn to love other people’s creativeness. There are similarities between transitions, transformations, and creativeness, but the big difference is that the motor of creativeness is inspiration. From the Latin, inspiration carries with it notions of breathing life to something new. Machiavelli cautioned the Prince against novelty: people won’t like it. Donald Meltzer says, in his book, The Apprehension of Beauty:

“Psycho-analytical contributions to any theory of inspiration and creativity must, of course, be derived from experience of the analytical process. In my opinion, although reference to aesthetic experiences past and current must necessarily make up some part of the patient’s material, the entry into the transference of an aesthetic apprehension of the analyst’s modes of thought, of the analytical method and of the process of development that it generates, makes a late appearance in the therapy.”

The “apprehension of the analyst’s modes of thought” stimulated me to create the concept of positive capability.

Seth: Can you give an example?

Franco: A beautiful example of positive capability is the way in which Søren Sveistrup, the screenwriter of the Danish TV show The Killing (Danish: Forbrydelsen, or The Crime), builds his episodes. Each episode, and each mystery, has to have some kind of myth, some kind of epic thing about it. His working methods are almost unique among television writers. Instead of writing scripts for the entire series, Sveistrup pens the show as it is being filmed. He seems to almost relish putting himself under enormous pressure to get the scripts finished in time. “It’s difficult—it is like if you have a train and the train is just behind you. It’s difficult to describe—if you imagine you’re laying the tracks for the train and the train is just behind you all the way.” I love it because it’s part of the game. Of course, the whole idea is a chase—a chase for truth, and the killer, but also the whole game is to get Sarah Lund into dangerous situations.

Seth: You mean that creativity is putting yourself in difficult situations.

Franco: Yes, that is the nature of the creative conflict between Negative and positive capability. We tend to abandon it because it increases anxiety of the unknown. But fundamentally the inspiration requires the creative feelings to be felt by feelings of responsibility.

Seth: What are these feelings of responsibility?

Franco: The courage to create what can be created, the serenity and patience to accept what cannot be created, and the wisdom to distinguish the one from the other.

Seth: Thank you, Franco, for being with us.

Franco: It has been a pleasure. Sorry for unanswering your questions.

Seth: Next time can you talk about the problem of feeling the feelings of the feelings?

Franco: Yes of course.

Franco Scabbiolo is an Italian born psychotherapist who lives and works in Oxford, England. For many years he worked closely with his mentor Donald Meltzer. His presentations focused for several years on Meltzer’s work and later evolved into presentations of his own evolving model, which he calls “an aesthetic compass for emotional experience.” He has been a supervisor and mentor to many psychotherapists in the Seattle community who value his sensibility and humanistic concern for a living psychoanalytic process that continues to evolve.

Categories: Feature InterviewPublished On: June 14th, 2021Tags: