President’s Letter

The Wound is the Place Where the Light Enters

On Thursday, May 28th, I woke to a voicemail from Tom Saunders, informing me that Austin Case, one of the founding members of COR, had passed away at age 90. While I never met Austin, I know Austin’s life is inextricably intertwined with COR’s origins and his spirit remains imbedded in COR’s collective psyche. The following day, protests and riots sprouted up across the U. S. in response to recent deaths of Black individuals, such as George Floyd, at the hands of law enforcement. Tension was palpable, as outrage and mourning permeated the U. S. collective psyche and nascent awareness was drawn to inequalities and injustices that the Black community, and other people of color, have experienced and continue to experience in our country. A week later, CHAZ (or CHOP) was founded near the old COR offices. In the backdrop of this simmering and conflictual emotional atmosphere, COVID-19, which was already responsible for approximately 100,00 deaths in the US, 400,000 worldwide, was a central health, social, economic, and psychological concern. These are all examples of the Devil Coming to Moscow, which I wrote about two letters ago in describing events that bring about inevitable and uninvited change in our internal world.

Miriam-Webster defines “catastrophe” as “a momentous tragic event ranging from extreme misfortune to utter overthrow or ruin.” However, an etymological study of the word reveals that it did not always denote solely destructive experience. The word was introduced into the English language in the 16th century as a theatrical term, denoting “the conclusion or final event of a dramatic work.” Another source defined it as a “reversal of what is expected.” The word was used to define the final event of a play, which brought about the final transformation of the unfolding plot, a pivotal event that changed the characters involved and the perception of the audience. Because many of the plays were tragedies, the word became connoted with tragic events. “Catastrophe” derives from the Greek stem katá-, meaning “down or against” and stréphō, meaning “turn.” The Greek word katastrophḗ meant “overturning, sudden turn.”

Our world and our organization have been going through, by many accounts, a catastrophe in this past five months. The emergence of COVID-19 has touched every dimension of our lives, from how we work to how we care for our patients, to how we socialize, and to how we care for our bodies. Even more importantly, it has changed our relationships with ourselves, our bodies, with others, technology, and disease, and with our mortality. The recent protests and riots aimed at questioning our own personal and collective unconscious racism, hate, and violence have changed our perspectives of ourselves, our friends, our politics and political structure, and our identity. COR has been touched, as the board of directors and members have been wrestling with questions around why we don’t have more Black members and people of color in our organization, or why there are not more Black people and other people of color included in the body of Object Relations literature and theory. We have gone through a personal and collective sudden change, what Bion might call a catastrophic change, and our organization, naturally, has as well.

Bion delineated two factors of transformation: 1) the change in form (trans-form) and 2) the part that does not change, or the invariant. In his conception, there is a part of internal and external reality that is in constant flux, ever changing, ever evolving. He describes O as the absolute reality, which is always hidden from us by our history and preconceived conceptions of the world. In times of catastrophic change, our constructed defenses against O, including our mind and identity, break down, and we catch glimpses through our history and preconceived conceptions of ourselves and the world, if only for moments. We are changed by these encounters, forever. These encounters with O feel catastrophic, partly because they confront our understanding of ourselves, like the protests and riots over race and inequality, COVID-19, and the loss of Austin Case. Such experiences provide us with opportunities to see through the vail of our history and preconceived conceptions of the world so we may have a closer understanding of deeper unconscious truth. Truth is the gift these experiences bring, but only if we let ourselves feel.

A foundational concept in Buddhism is anicca, often translated to impermanence, which describes a fundamental law of the universe that everything is always in flux, everything is always changing. Much like Bion’s conception of transformations in O, it is in experiencing anicca that we come closer to truth, both about ourselves and about the universe in which we live. This concept is also experienced in the Christian tradition, in the imagery of the death and resurrection of Jesus. In both traditions, through suffering the impermanence of the universe, we gain access to truth, and hopefully compassion and love. Both of these traditions suggest catastrophes are not only inevitable to our growth, but essential. “Things falling apart is a kind of testing and also a kind of healing. We think that the point is to pass the test or to overcome the problem, but the truth is that things don’t really get solved,” Pema Chödrön, a Buddhist scholar wrote. “They come together and they fall apart. They come together again and fall apart again. It’s just like that. The healing comes from letting there be room for all this to happen: room for grief, for relief, for misery, for joy.”

As therapists, we are in the business of change. Our occupation rests upon the idea of impermanence, because we believe that humans change, and that such change can be facilitated and supported. As I have encountered with patients in therapy, and in my personal therapy, we do not get to control when change comes about, nor predict what form it will present. It usually surprises us. In such moments of surprise, we realize that even we, as facilitators of change, unconsciously wish for things to remain the same, in the patient and in ourselves. Freud spoke to this wish in the idea of the death drive, which describes our unconscious wish to calcify life into a deadened, tensionless existence. We mistakenly believe this process provides safety. Luckily, as we can see in the past five months, life has a way of changing us, even when we fight against it. We have words like “catastrophe” and “disaster” that reflect our dislike for change. There is Taoist parable that goes like this:

There was an old farmer who had worked his crops for many years. One day his horse ran away. Upon hearing the news, his neighbors came to visit. “Such bad luck,” they said sympathetically. “Maybe,” the farmer replied. The next morning the horse returned, bringing with it three other wild horses. “How wonderful,” the neighbors exclaimed. “Maybe,” replied the old man. The following day, his son tried to ride one of the untamed horses, was thrown, and broke his leg. The neighbors again came to offer their sympathy for what they called his “misfortune.” “Maybe,” answered the farmer. The day after, military officials came to the village to draft young men into the army. Seeing that the son’s leg was broken, they passed him by. The neighbors congratulated the farmer on how well things had turned out. “Maybe,” said the farmer.

The parable exemplifies the way we rush to label change (revealing our splitting processes) in order to make sense of it and ease our fear of the unknown.

At COR, my hope is that we can sit with the necessary suffering involved with change, allowing ourselves personally and communally to be transformed by it. My hope is that our history and preconceived conceptions of ourselves, our community, and our world are deconstructed by these catastrophes, and an invariant becomes readily visible, the spirit of COR which began with Austin Case and the founding members of COR 25 years ago. Although our understanding deepens and transforms and our organizational identity changes, my hope is that the spirit of COR becomes more fully felt as catastrophic events in our external world burn away calcified, dead experience, making room for baby experience. My hope is the spirit revealed is a safe place, internally and externally, in which we are able to hold the vast expanse of human experience, the joy, the sadness, the rage, the loss, the love. In summary, in these unsettling times of suffering, I am suggesting COR adopt Rumi’s attitude towards catastrophe and change as expressed in these words:

I said: What about my heart?
He said: Tell me what you hold inside it?

I said: Pain and sorrow.
He said: Stay with it. The wound is the place where the Light enters you.

Collin McFadden

COR President

Categories: President's LetterPublished On: July 1st, 2020Tags: